登陆注册
15705500000014

第14章 THE VOTER AND THE TWO VOICES(2)

Nearly all the great newspapers,both pompous and frivolous,will declare dogmatically day after day,until every one half believes it,that red and green are the only two colours in the paint-box.THE OBSERVER will say:"No one who knows the solid framework of politics or the emphatic first principles of an Imperial people can suppose for a moment that there is any possible compromise to be made in such a matter;we must either fulfil our manifest racial destiny and crown the edifice of ages with the august figure of a Green Premier,or we must abandon our heritage,break our promise to the Empire,fling ourselves into final anarchy,and allow the flaming and demoniac image of a Red Premier to hover over our dissolution and our doom."The DAILY MAIL would say:

"There is no halfway house in this matter;it must be green or red.We wish to see every honest Englishman one colour or the other."And then some funny man in the popular Press would star the sentence with a pun,and say that the DAILY MAIL liked its readers to be green and its paper to be read.But no one would even dare to whisper that there is such a thing as yellow.

For the purposes of pure logic it is clearer to argue with silly examples than with sensible ones:because silly examples are simple.But I could give many grave and concrete cases of the kind of thing to which I refer.

In the later part of the Boer War both parties perpetually insisted in every speech and pamphlet that annexation was inevitable and that it was only a question whether Liberals or Tories should do it.It was not inevitable in the least;it would have been perfectly easy to make peace with the Boers as Christian nations commonly make peace with their conquered enemies.Personally I think that it would have been better for us in the most selfish sense,better for our pocket and prestige,if we had never effected the annexation at all;but that is a matter of opinion.

What is plain is that it was not inevitable;it was not,as was said,the only possible course;there were plenty of other courses;there were plenty of other colours in the box.Again,in the discussion about Socialism,it is repeatedly rubbed into the public mind that we must choose between Socialism and some horrible thing that they call Individualism.I don't know what it means,but it seems to mean that anybody who happens to pull out a plum is to adopt the moral philosophy of the young Horner--and say what a good boy he is for helping himself.

It is calmly assumed that the only two possible types of society are a Collectivist type of society and the present society that exists at this moment and is rather like an animated muck-heap.It is quite unnecessary to say that I should prefer Socialism to the present state of things.Ishould prefer anarchism to the present state of things.But it is simply not the fact that Collectivism is the only other scheme for a more equal order.A Collectivist has a perfect right to think it the only sound scheme;but it is not the only plausible or possible scheme.We might have peasant proprietorship;we might have the compromise of Henry George;we might have a number of tiny communes;we might have co-operation;we might have Anarchist Communism;we might have a hundred things.I am not saying that any of these are right,though I cannot imagine that any of them could be worse than the present social madhouse,with its top-heavy rich and its tortured poor;but I say that it is an evidence of the stiff and narrow alternative offered to the civic mind,that the civic mind is not,generally speaking,conscious of these other possibilities.The civic mind is not free or alert enough to feel how much it has the world before it.There are at least ten solutions of the Education question,and no one knows which Englishmen really want.For Englishmen are only allowed to vote about the two which are at that moment offered by the Premier and the Leader of the Opposition.There are ten solutions of the drink question;and no one knows which the democracy wants;for the democracy is only allowed to fight about one Licensing Bill at a time.

So that the situation comes to this:The democracy has a right to answer questions,but it has no right to ask them.It is still the political aristocracy that asks the questions.And we shall not be unreasonably cynical if we suppose that the political aristocracy will always be rather careful what questions it asks.And if the dangerous comfort and self-flattery of modern England continues much longer there will be less democratic value in an English election than in a Roman saturnalia of slaves.For the powerful class will choose two courses of action,both of them safe for itself,and then give the democracy the gratification of taking one course or the other.The lord will take two things so much alike that he would not mind choosing from them blindfold--and then for a great jest he will allow the slaves to choose.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 灭劫神主

    灭劫神主

    劫要灭我,我先灭劫!……自古以来,生伴随死,起伴随落。杀戮伴随着劫难。诸国争霸,群雄并起;宗派林立,血雨腥风;万族论道,劫难再现……大千世界,谁主沉浮?在这个充满劫难的时代中,姬龙踏破九天十地,逆天夺命,灭劫破灾,斩破三千宇宙!
  • 凡命修仙

    凡命修仙

    浩瀚的修仙界,不一样的世界,不一样的人生,带给你不一样的感受
  • 夏末姜跱,骞墨相思

    夏末姜跱,骞墨相思

    在逝去的岁月中,有没有一个人他曾令你魂牵梦绕,他曾令你牵肠挂肚他或许成为了你生命中最重要的一部分又或者分道扬镳,从此便是陌路人正如淳淳奶香,馥郁酒香留下的,不过是刻骨铭心罢了……
  • 燃烧之主

    燃烧之主

    穿越到武道天赋一般的少年身上,居然激活了游戏中术士的模板。法师战士们颤抖吧,燃烧军团会吞噬你们!
  • 未来故事之花形

    未来故事之花形

    每个人或许总有一段哭笑不得的人生经历,也许令你刻骨铭心也可能令你痛不欲生,是爱情是亲情。人生中的每一个分岔的路口就或许就应该是人生的转折点,因为我们的选择不同可能我们未来就不同!人有一半的时间可能都会在做选择,当然有错有对,可是当我们选择错了的时候怎么办呢?错了我们就要承受!你知道人活着最纠结的事情是什么?其实就是无能为力!
  • 农桑衣食撮要

    农桑衣食撮要

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 是谁冰封了她的心

    是谁冰封了她的心

    冰封的心,等待解封。曾经的不相信,慢慢的因为他所给的温暖,所相信。谢谢你,让我找回了感情,谢谢你,让我懂得了温暖……
  • 清穿之禛心若初

    清穿之禛心若初

    相隔了数百年的时光,这一场因缘际会的相遇,已不仅仅是缘分,这是命中注定的交集,是不可违逆的轮回……云初:我跨越一切,只为来到你身边胤禛:我心空置半生,原来只为等你胤祚:你是最美的风景,我从不曾忘记命运如果能被更改,那便不是命运爱情如果有理智,那便不是爱情
  • 远古圣尊

    远古圣尊

    【热血免费】神魔大陆,人,妖,魔,灵四族分而共存。十五年前的一场人魔大战,打破了大陆的统治格局,人族强势崛起。元从人魔大战的禁区踏入人族统治国-大元王朝,被天意抛弃的他,面对一个个阴谋,一次次暗杀,百般阻挠,能否强大自己,找出当年人魔大战的内幕?强者,决定权使终在自己的手中。
  • 绝世圣仙

    绝世圣仙

    他,身具两极之体,本应三岁而殇,却被人赐下奇药活了下来。他,踏入修真界,历情劫、杀劫、死劫,万般劫难加身却从未放弃。他,一生寻找自身和天地之谜,看尽人世间的丑与恶。他,徘徊在正与邪的边缘,陷入重重迷雾,无数个谜局当中。届时,毗邻星现,是圈套?还是乾坤之变?惟有挥剑入天道,杀伐证穹心。